Captain America: Brave New World
Anthony Mackie as Sam Wilsons/Captain America
The Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) has gone through a lot — multiversal madness, cosmic chaos, and a truckload of CGI-heavy extravaganzas. Captain America: Brave New World ditches much of that for a more grounded, espionage-driven narrative reminiscent of Phases 1 and 2.
On paper, this should be a welcome return to form. However, while the themes are timely and ambitious, the execution feels undercooked.
MCU Expansion or Just Easter Eggs?
The film kicks off with a bang — or rather, a lore dump. A TV news broadcast sets the stage, referencing the Celestial Island from Eternals and introducing Adamantium, the indestructible metal synonymous with Wolverine. It’s a clear signal that Marvel is laying the groundwork for the future, including the inevitable arrival of the X-Men.
With Sam Wilson now fully stepping up to the Captain America mantle, the film follows his battle against a shadowy international conspiracy. With a promising setup, featuring espionage, false-flag operations, and political corruption all playing into the narrative. There’s even a not-so-subtle allegory for the current state of global politics, with the U.S. government seizing resources it doesn’t own and escalating tensions with allies.
However, the brisk pace of the film, while preventing it from dragging, also makes it feel like nothing of real consequence happens. The film’s attempt to juggle so many elements results in a story that feels overstuffed yet underwhelming.
Anthony Mackie Shines, But the Villains Falter
Anthony Mackie is undoubtedly the highlight of the film. As Sam Wilson, he brings a grounded, charismatic energy to the role, arguably even surpassing Chris Evans, and proving he’s more than capable of carrying the shield. His new suit and powers add a dynamic edge to the action sequences, even if the rapid-cut editing sometimes undermines their impact.
Unfortunately, the villains don’t fare as well. Particularly Tim Blake Nelson as Samuel Sterns, have all the hallmarks of classic Marvel antagonists — a brilliant evil genius who is diabolically underdeveloped. Their motivations are generic, and despite some compelling performances, they don’t leave a lasting impact.
Technical Flaws and Political Allegories
The film’s technical shortcomings are hard to ignore. The CGI, particularly in the Red Hulk scenes, is distractingly poor, pulling you out of the action. The Automated Dialogue Replacement (ADR) is equally jarring, especially in the operating theatre scene with Sam and Bucky, where the audio mix feels off.
On a thematic level, Brave New World attempts to mirror the current state of American politics, with its depiction of a divided nation, crumbling institutions, and a president making false promises. While the allegory is timely, it’s handled with a heavy hand, lacking the nuance that made Captain America: The Winter Soldier such a standout.
The post-credit scene teases a path toward Secret Invasion or Avengers vs X-Men, hinting at bigger things to come. But for now, Captain America: Brave New World feels like a stepping stone rather than a destination. It’s a solid, if unspectacular, entry into the MCU that sets the stage for the future without ever fully capturing the magic of the past.
Support Pario Magazine
$2.50 / month
Early Access
subscribe
