Send In The Clowns: Joker: Folie à Deux vs Terrifier 3
Art The Clown from Terrifier 3
If ever there was a year for sad clowns, 2024 took the cake - and smeared it across the screen. In Joker: Folie à Deux, Joaquin Phoenix returns with his brooding, melancholic Arthur, while Terrifier 3’s Art the Clown goes full throttle on twisted terror. But, who gives audiences a more memorable nightmare? While Arthur’s busy singing the blues, Art is busy crafting some of the most gruesome kills in recent horror history. Let’s dive into this chaotic carnival of despair and dismemberment to find out which clown truly reigns supreme in cinema’s dark side this year.
Cinematic Style: Raw Realism vs. Unfiltered Gore
If Joker: Folie à Deux is a melancholy waltz into a tormented mind, Terrifier 3 is a blood-soaked rampage through horror's most twisted corridors. Joker: Folie à Deux leans heavily on the art-house aesthetic, with striking visuals and a focus on Joaquin Phoenix's profound performance. However, the storytelling occasionally falters, feeling disjointed as if designed solely to showcase Phoenix’s acting chops. In stark contrast, Terrifier 3 revels in raw horror and visceral effects, with creative kills that are gorier than ever. It pays tribute to horror classics like The Crow and The Exorcist, delighting fans with its grisly artistry while unapologetically indulging in genre clichés.
Characters: The Tragic Joker vs. the Terror of Art the Clown
Joker: Folie à Deux introduces Lady Gaga as Harleen “Lee” Quinzel alongside Phoenix’s Arthur Fleck, yet their dynamic lacks the impact one might expect. Arthur’s transformation feels tragic but hollow; he’s a tortured soul from whom audiences may find it difficult to draw empathy. In contrast, Terrifier 3 centres on the silent but deeply menacing Art the Clown, who wordlessly exudes terror. His actions, though vile, captivate in a way that Arthur’s internal turmoil does not. Art’s chilling silence and dark humour, set against his increasingly sinister persona, give him an undeniable presence that resonates with horror fans.
Storytelling & Plot Depth: Unconventional Drama vs. Fractured Lore
Joaquin Phoenix as Arthur Fleck & Lady Gaga as Harleen “Lee” Quinzel in Joker: Folie à Deux
Narrative pacing in Joker: Folie à Deux is deliberate, bordering on ponderous, as it explores Arthur’s descent with tragic overtones, albeit without a cohesive arc. Some fans of the 2019 Joker may feel Folie à Deux misses the mark, feeling more like a complex art project than a true sequel. Meanwhile, Terrifier 3 brings new layers to its own mythos, although it sometimes gets tangled in its own lore. The expansion of Becky as an even more disturbing character expands Art’s nightmarish world, but the plot may feel convoluted for some, leaving audiences to focus more on the atmosphere than on storyline coherence.
Music and Atmosphere: A Discordant Dance vs. Chilling Silence
The musical scenes in Joker: Folie à Deux, while ambitious, often detract from the film’s emotional core, with lifeless, incongruent numbers that neither enhance the story nor capture Arthur’s psychological depth. The music feels like a missed opportunity, breaking the film’s mood rather than enhancing it. By contrast, Terrifier 3 is driven by a more understated yet effective atmosphere of dread, underscored by silence and tension-building moments that make Art’s gruesome actions even more jarring. The lack of dialogue, other than screams of agony & terror from Art’s victims in key scenes amplifies the horror, emphasising the chilling unpredictability of Art’s world.
Budget & Overall Impact: Artistry Over Expense
With a modest $2 million budget, Terrifier 3 surpasses expectations, demonstrating that creativity often trumps dollars. In comparison, Joker: Folie à Deux was backed by a hefty $200 million, yet it struggles to deliver a compelling experience that matches its predecessor. Terrifier 3 feels like a labour of love for horror aficionados, while Joker: Folie à Deux comes across as an overly elaborate attempt to extend a story that perhaps should have remained a standalone. For fans of horror and dark character studies alike, Terrifier 3 holds an edge with its unapologetic embrace of terror over artistry, making it a more engaging ride despite its flaws.
In the end, Joker: Folie à Deux and Terrifier 3 are like two tragic clowns who took very different paths: one cries his way through a musical therapy session, while the other laughs (silently, of course) while painting the walls red.
Support Pario Magazine
$2.50 / month
Early Access
subscribe
